top of page

2017 Edmonton city election flawed due to ward system

  • Tom Monto
  • Mar 28, 2021
  • 2 min read

Edmonton city elections are conducted in 12 separate electoral contests.


This division into 12 different contests, and the division of the voters into 12 different sections, means that:

many votes are wasted --- more than half the votes did not elect anyone

many voters are disregarded --- more than half the voters did not see their choice elected

some voters cannot vote for whom they want to see on city council because they happen to live in a different ward,

it does not produce the election of the most popular candidates -- those who get more votes than others may not be elected.


This list of the 21 people who received the most votes in the 2017 elections -- yes elections, as there was not just one but 12 separate contests -- showed how unfair the election system is -

a person who received 5282 votes was not elected while a person who received 3455 was.


2017 Edmonton city election

Candidates in order of popularity:
[any who received more than 3400 votes]
Michael Walters 11,678          Ward 10  (elected)
Andrew Knack  10,091 	        Ward 1   (elected)
Tim Cartmell 9160 		Ward 9   (elected)
Mike Nickel 9148 		Ward 11  (elected)
Scott McKeen 7774 		Ward 6   (elected)
Bev Esslinger 7475  		Ward 2   (elected)
Moe Banga 6636 		        Ward 12  (elected)
Ben Henderson 6235 		Ward 8   (elected)
Sarah Hamilton 6156 		Ward 5   (elected)
Vieri Berretti 5282 		Ward 10
Bill Knight 4958 		Ward 6
Rob Agostinis 4763 		Ward 9
Karen Tang 4361 		Ward 11
Jon Dziadyk 4354 		Ward 3   (elected)
Tony Caterina 4017 		Ward 7   (elected)
Kirsten Goa 3890 		Ward 8
Dave Loken 3890 		Ward 3
Kris Andreychuk 3852 	        Ward 7
David Xiao 3626 		Ward 5
Sandy Pon 3480 		        Ward 9
Aaron Paquettee 3455 	        Ward 4   (elected).
===========================


These are all reasons why the FPTP in 12 separate wards needs to be changed -- we need to establish multi-member wards or at-large elections and each voter casting only one vote each, so 
-- a much smaller portion of the votes are all that is wasted
-- a great proportion of the voters see their choice elected
-- fewer voters are separated from their preferred candidates due to ward boundaries
-- those who are more popular than others are elected while those with fewer votes are not.

==============================================================











Recent Posts

See All

Comments


© 2019 by Tom Monto. Proudly created with Wix.com

History | Tom Monto Montopedia is a blog about the history, present, and future of Edmonton, Alberta. Run by Tom Monto, Edmonton historian. Fruits of my research, not complete enough to be included in a book, and other works.

bottom of page