Alberta PR and Electoral Reform in books
- Tom Monto
- Apr 25
- 3 min read
Updated: Apr 25
Here I give book titles that exemplify or hint at different advances and foibles of Alberta provincial election system.
1917 "Give your other vote to the sister" by
The campaign slogan of Roberta MacAdams that capitalized on the two votes cast by soldiers in the army, in the only use of Block voting in the 1917 Alberta election.
MacAdams and Louise McKinney (back in Alberta) were elected, the first women legislators elected in the British Empire.
1921 Politics and Perennials by Barbara Villy Cormack
Irene Parlby first woman cabinet minister in Alberta, in the UFA government.
The UFA government brought in "PR-light" - STV in the cities.
Brownlee by Franklin
John E. Brownlee became premier in 1925.
1924 A Key to PR by John D. Hunt was self-published
1929 Person's Case
Emily Murphy never in gov't
appointed Senate
Ernest Manning
1956 cancelled PR and IRV
FPTP came in, and that helped his government take more seats next time.
And stay in power another 15 years.
Grant Notley by Howard Leeson
unsuccessful in Edm (ran in Edm-Norwood in 1967 -
actually no CCF or NDP elected in Edmonton from when FPTP was brought in until 1982
1971 he ran in Spirit River-Fairview as parachute candidate,
saw it would be easier to be elected there (less susceptible to gerrymandering)
became voice for workers and farmers across the province
1993 NDP MLAs not re-elected in part, due to gerrymandering
the city being divided into 16 or so districts made it easy to gerrymander.
==============================
More info on Alberta political history and democratic reform
1910s democratic strivings expressed by drive for Direct Legislation
Direct Legislation is Initiative, Referendum and Recall
achieved Initiative
1912 tenants getting vote in Edmonton city elections
first labour-oriented city councillors elected - James East, Rice Sheppard, James Kinney
1917 "Give your other vote to the sister" Roberta MacAdams
1921 drive for PR
but Liberal gov't merely brought in city-wide districts and Block Voting
1921 UFA elected usually with majority of votes in rural districts.
Liberals took all five Edm seats with about a third of the city vote.
1924 UFA fulfilled its promise to have PR partially just in cities
1935 Social Credit gov't elected
brought in Recall then dropped it
1955 SC felt snubbed by "losing" four seats in districts where SC candidate was first in the 1st Round of counting.
SC used "high" incidence of spoiled votes as rationale
but that was partially self-caused. (changed its rules concerning use of X voting)
government thought that FPTP would give it more seats
after change to FPTP, the government's expectations were proved right in 1959 when it took every seat in Edm and all but one in Calgary
SC then suffered un-desired defeat in 1971 when it took about a third of seats with 40 percent of votes
-- Conservatives were more popular with 46 percent of votes, and took about 20 percent more seats than its vote share.
1975 election result was even worse for Social Credit party, as it suffered even more under FPTP --
- it took only four seats with 18 percent of the vote (it was due about 15).
But that merely demonstrated that SC party was not that important
by 1971 SC had become just a conservative party.
===============================================
Comments